Username:    Password:
Thanks for stopping by...

On Tasting
The World Versus Robert M. Parker, Part Three
Saturday, 18th March, 2006  - David Farmer

Robert M Parker’s thoughts about the Mount Mary Quintets has sparked off an interesting debate are here we explore how wine critics react to different tasting styles. The first two parts of this story are Sharp Differences of Opinion Over Mount Mary and The Differences of Opinion Continue: Mount Mary Quintets vs. Robert M. Parker Jr. Part 2.

Considering the high profile of James Halliday, Robert Parker and others, it is worth probing a bit deeper and to see if we can understand why they disagree. It is also puzzling that such recognized judges of wine can have such a diverse view over the Mount Mary Quintets, not of a single wine where differences are quite common, but about a sequence of wines that stretches back decades. It is rare for major wine figures to disagree so widely about a wine style.

It would be putting it mildly to say that Parker has irritated the cream of the U.K. wine press for some time. Some of this is because he has challenged their title of being the world’s most influential world wine critics and in the American market has a great deal more influence.

Some comments taken from 'Wine – A Life Uncorked', the latest work by Hugh Johnson show his dislike of Parkers wine views, "Imperial hegemony lives in Washington and the dictator of taste in Baltimore... Taste in the past was largely a matter of harmless fashion. In American hands, it feels more like a moral crusade. Robert Parker deals in absolutes, and castigates those he sees as backsliders."

Recently Andrew Jefford an English wine writer interviewed Johnson about his new work and asked about his views of Parker: "and I put it to Johnson that Parker's life's work had been predicated on the fact that there is 'better' and 'worse' in wine, whereas Johnson's own life's work was chiefly concerned with the word 'different'.

"'That is so fundamental,' he agrees. 'And also fundamental is the fact that Parker feels he has the right to tick off people who don't do "better". Whereas I don't feel any such right.' In his book, Johnson describes himself as a 'relativist. I look for the virtues proper to each wine and enjoy them for what they are. I look on fundamentalist judgements as dangerous and misleading.'"

Similar views have been expressed by author Jancis Robinson and probably reflect at least partly the views of Michael Broadbent and other senior members of the English wine press. It would seem that our senior judges like James Halliday, Brian Croser and Len Evans incline to these views about Parker as well.

This is what James Halliday said in the recent speech to the Wine Press Club of N.S.W.; "If, as is likely the case and irrespective of the country of origin, for Parker, big is good, bigger is better, and biggest is best..." For the full speech go to "Thank You Mr. Evans and Sorry Mr. Parker"

It has of course been recognized for some time that Parker favours rich, big, bold styles of wine and these frequently come with high alcohol. Thus he has been a huge fan of reds such as those made in the Barossa and McLaren Vale. His enthusiasm for these styles has been of great benefit to these regions and his general support for many Australian wines has had a profound impact on giving winemakers confidence and has of course led to a following for these styles in America which has led to large price increases.

Still while he has shown a preference for deep, rich, full bodied styles, and this applies not only to Australia but also and famously to Bordeaux and Burgundy. Parker has tasted for a long time and across a great spectrum of wines, probably more than any other commentator, such that we find it difficult to join those who say that he does not also connect with delicate, more refined wine styles.

It is some of the other things that Halliday said in this speech that made us raise our eyebrows. Glug has after all set up its headquarters in the Barossa because we love the wines and believe our customers do as well.

As background to his speech Halliday analysed the trophy winners of the last six Royal Sydney Wine Shows, some 118 in all and found the three regions that can be associated with big, bold, reds had hardly won any trophies and went on to say; "These three regions are overwhelmingly the birthplace of the monstrous red wine so beloved of Robert Parker, yet they are outranked by Riverina, King Valley, Orange, Grampians. Sorry Mr. Parker whichever way you want to look at it the Australian Show judges profoundly disagree with you".

Indeed they do, at least in Sydney, then we pondered the meaning of this comment; "At the same time the composition of the judging panels goes a long way to explaining why Parkeresque wines seldom achieve any significant recognition. Under the Chairmanship of Brian Croser, there has been an emphatic instruction to all judges to reward wines with finesse and elegance and to penalize over-ripe, over extracted wines. I can assure you there will be no change of policy under my forthcoming Chairmanship".

Halliday continued; "The near absence of Barossa Valley trophies is explained by two factors: most do not enter the show system, and those that do, have negligible success. It is, if you like, a simultaneous poke in the eye for Messrs Parker and Kramer alike." (The American wine writer Matt Kramer has recently made comments about our judging system including that it suffers from 'taste fixing'.)

We think a good hearty debate is fine though we do wonder whether it is a good idea to poke a stick in the eye of the one American personality who has done the most to champion one of our wine styles. After all every one in the industry is aware we must increase our export sales of premium wines which have stagnated. Marketing practice has always taught us that you run with what is working not with what you would like to work.

Halliday does show that he understands that some consumers like these styles of wine; "What, then, about Robert Parker? Well, while many of us baulk at the Parker red wine style, we must remember that these wines have an avid reception from influential and wealthy connoisseurs". Indeed the Barossa big red style is marching up the ranks of the Langtons 101 wine classification and forcing out, cool climate wines. See our thoughts on the Langtons classification at A Look at Langtons Classification from 1991 to 2005.

He continues; "The real challenge is to persuade Parker et al that mature Hunter, and top flight dry riesling-young and old-are as great as they are unique." This is true and never has there been seen such a concerted effort to reward these styles in the Australian judging ring. Isn’t it a trifle odd that the Adelaide Wine Show gives so many trophies to aged Hunter whites?

So where does this leave us about Mount Mary Quintets? Our view is that Parker may have been a bit harsh though we will report back after we have tracked down a bottle or two to judge for ourselves.

On the bigger matter about what Parker likes and his world wide influence we remain positive and cannot see what the problem is except he has a bigger following than the critics do. And yes we do confess to quite a liking for the bold Barossa, Clare and McLaren Vale styles. His influence may wane in time and we urge winemakers across the country to grab as much of his time as he will allow and enjoy his influence.

We understand that a lot of Parkers wines are not tasted masked and this does worry us and no doubt this upsets our judging fraternity though whatever the result of this at least a style of Aussie wine has come out on top.

Lastly we get the distinct impression Parker finds these attacks immensely amusing particularly now that he’s got the whole of the established old school against him which means he can look over his shoulder with a great deal of pleasure. Come in spinner can be heard.

La Tâche 1962 and Grand Old Fake Bottles

Tuesday, 19th December, 2017

How You Can Drink Smarter

Monday, 28th August, 2017

Thoughts on Wine and Alcohol

Monday, 28th August, 2017

Which is Better - Young Wine or Aged?

Wednesday, 27th August, 2014

John Moody and Brave or Foolish Judging by Winestate September/October 2013 : Part 2.

Monday, 21st July, 2014

My Replies to Frequently Asked Questions

Sunday, 22nd June, 2014

John Moody and Brave or Foolish Judging by Winestate September/October 2013 : Part 1

Thursday, 1st May, 2014

Tastings Wine Scores and Shapley Values

Thursday, 27th March, 2014

Views on Tasting with Penfolds Notes for the Record

Thursday, 27th February, 2014

Broken Glasses, Tasting Cups, Chinese Misadventures and Tailgating

Thursday, 8th August, 2013

A Wine for Richard

Monday, 5th August, 2013

Morrisons - Never Fail Method for Buying Wine

Tuesday, 9th July, 2013

Writing Tasting Notes about Great Wine

Wednesday, 2nd May, 2013

Is a Tasting Note Helpful when Shopping?

Wednesday, 24th April, 2013

Do Tasting Notes Have any Value?

Friday, 22nd March, 2013

The Five Secrets of Stylish Women Applied to Drinking Wine

Tuesday, 12th February, 2013

Playing the 'Hit Me' Wine Game

Monday, 10th December, 2012

A Response to an eBay Customer About Barossa Cabernet

Monday, 27th August, 2012

Starting a Cellar and General Thoughts on Ageing Wines - The Experience of a Hardcore Wine Collector

Monday, 20th August, 2012

Starting a Cellar and General Thoughts on Ageing Wines

Wednesday, 18th July, 2012

Do Tastings Protect the Brand Image of Wine Australia?

Tuesday, 17th April, 2012

Do the Waitrose Taste Test

Sunday, 26th February, 2012

Wine Writers Misleading Customers

Tuesday, 10th January, 2012

Steps in Becoming a Wine Snob

Saturday, 10th December, 2011

A Morning at the Mount Barker WA Wine Show

Sunday, 20th November, 2011

Natural Flavours from Wine and Beer Yeasts

Friday, 26th August, 2011

Status in St Emilion Raises Issues

Sunday, 24th July, 2011

What Should You Pay for Great Wine?

Sunday, 15th May, 2011

Gordon Ramsay Says "Consult the Sommelier" - Is He Right?

Tuesday, 13th July, 2010

Driven to Drink - A Reflection by Frank Devine

Friday, 25th June, 2010

The John Vickery Leo Buring Tasting 1997

Monday, 24th May 2010

Tasting Budget Reds in London

Tuesday, 27th April 2010

A Rosemount Story from Tesco UK

Tuesday, 23rd March, 2010

Descriptions of Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc from Unexpected Sources

Tuesday, 23rd March, 2010

Sadat X Amusing? Yes. But Not Yet a Challenger to Robert Parker

Thursday, 18th February, 2010

Tasting the Latest Noon Wines

Friday, 5th February, 2010

The Barossa Wine Show Public Tasting 19th September
Part 3 of the Barossa Tastings

Monday, 4th January, 2010

The Power of Gold

Wednesday, 25th November, 2009

First Write the Review then Taste the Wine

Wednesday, 25th November, 2009

The Artisans of the Barossa 12th September
Part 2 of the Barossa Tastings

Friday, 30th October, 2009

The Whites do go Better With Fish

Friday, 30th October, 2009

A Parker Tasting Should Make Us Pause

Tuesday, 13th October, 2009

Why You Drink Champagne by the Sea

Thursday, 8th October, 2009

Tasting at Three Barossa Wine Shows
Part 1 - The Small Winemakers Show

Sunday, 4th October, 2009

It's In The Bubbles, Stupid

Friday, 2nd October, 2009

How Good is Your Palate?

Monday, 21st September, 2009

Another Know All Wine Wanker

Monday, 21st September, 2009

Further Thoughts on the Australian Wine Show System

Thursday, 3rd September, 2009

Wine Advice from Craigslist

Thursday, 3rd September, 2009

Comparing Wine Types and Dog Breeds

Saturday, 1st August, 2009

Electronic Experts Give Wine Advice

Monday, 15th June, 2009

In Search of a Holy Grail

Monday, 5th May, 2009

The Gimblett Gravels Travelling Road Show Surprises London

Monday, 20th April, 2009

The Beauty of the Five Point Judging System

Thursday, 26th March, 2009

Ideas for a New Wine Judging Scale

Thursday, 12th March, 2009

The First Growth Gimbletts

Monday, 26th January, 2009

The Story of One Lonely Bottle

Friday, 26th December, 2008

The Future of Capital City Wine Shows

Friday, 5th December, 2008

The More You Spend the Better the Taste

Friday, 2nd May, 2008

The Key to Tasting Wines

Friday, 11th April, 2008

Buying Wines That Have a Sense of Place

Friday, 11th April, 2008

What Are We to Make Of Wine Tasting Notes

Monday, 4th February, 2007

Study of the Label Alters Our Tastes

Sunday, 9th December, 2007

One in Five Cannot Smell Alpha-ylangene

Monday, 24th September, 2007

Charles Must Love It

Friday, 24th August, 2007

Liking Rough Red

Thursday, 28th June, 2007

The Ultimate Masked Bottle

Firday, 24th May, 2007

Create the Atmosphere for the Tasting Result You Want

Monday, 19th March, 2007

Confessions of Wine Deceit, Other Deceptions and Fooling Yourself

Monday, 29th January, 2007

Two Sides of the Wine Coin

Sunday, 12th November, 2006

Wine Labels, Ranking, Ratings, Experts and Wine Prices

Friday, 27th October, 2006

A Story About Verdelho

Wednesday, 4th October, 2006

The Magnetic Appeal of Wine

Sunday, 24th September, 2006

Geology Cannot be Found In Wine

Thursday, 18th September, 2006

More on the Impact of Scoring Wines Out of 100

Thursday, 14th September, 2006

How a Three Star Wine Became a 90 Point Wine

Saturday, 9th September, 2006

High Alcohol - The Debate Rolls On

Tuesday, 5th September, 2006

So You Suffer from Anosmia

Monday, 7th August, 2006

Can’t Tell Your Brett from Oak Flavours

Tuesday, 18th July, 2006

Terroir - Can It Possible Shine Through the Background Noise

Tuesday, 4th July, 2006

A Little Spat Over Chateau Pavie

Thursday, 15th June, 2006

After All This Time - Now They Tell Us

Tuesday, 13th June, 2006

Winemaking and the French Touch

Friday, 9th June, 2006

The Judgement of Paris Part II

Monday, 29th May, 2006

Why Do Chardonnays Seldom Win Trophies?

Friday, 5th May, 2006

The Other French Paradox

Tuesday, 2nd May, 2006

Show Me the Chardonnay Tasting

Sunday, 30th April, 2006

Judging Wine and the View of the American 'Wine Spectator'

Thursday, 6th April, 2006

The World Versus Robert M. Parker, Part Three

Saturday, 18th March, 2006

Halliday v Parker Continues to Attract International Attention

Thursday, 5th January, 2005

"Thank You Mr. Evans and Sorry Mr. Parker"

Thursday, 8th December, 2005

The Differences of Opinion Continue: Mount Mary Quintets vs. Robert M. Parker Jr. Part 2

Monday, 5th December, 2005

Sharp Differences of Opinion Over Mount Mary

Monday, 14th November, 2005

The Views of the Economists With a Sense of Humour

Friday, 14th October, 2005

Wine Quality: Does Terroir Matter?

Friday, 14th October, 2005

Thoughts on Wine Judging

Thursday, 13th October, 2005

What You See Affects What You Smell and Taste

Tuesday, 13th September, 2005

The New Taste of Wine

Friday, 2nd September, 2005

Consumers Disagree with Wine Experts

Saturday, 27th August, 2005

Drinking From Special Wine Glasses

Thursday, 4th August, 2005

Now, This Wine Drinks Well, Night After Night

Monday, 18th April, 2005

Corks, Stelvin Caps and Oxygen

Wednesday, 6th April 2005

A Peep Behind the Wine Show Door

Thursday, 17 March 2005

Going To Your Second Wine Tasting

Saturday, 11th December, 2004

What You Bring to Your First Wine Tasting

Saturday, 4th December, 2004

What Do Show Medals Mean - Part 2

Tuesday, 7th December, 2004

What Do Show Medals Mean - Part 1

Friday, 3rd September, 2004

©2019 Glug  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |   RSS Feed
Liquor Licensing Act 1997: It is an offence to sell or supply liquor to a person under the age of 18 years, or to obtain liquor on behalf of a person under the age of 18 years.
All transactions in $AUD. This web site is operated by Glug Management Company Pty Ltd ABN: 64 116 647 780 Licence No: 57701982