The Liquor Wars - Woolworths is Killing Coles
Tuesday, 8th November, 2011
- David Farmer
The country would be better served if Woolworths liquor and Coles liquor were about the same size and I base this on the belief that two goliaths would be better than one. Woolworths though are charging ahead at such a rate that the gap is widening and it's now beyond Coles to draw closer. This conclusion has been reached by simply considering the cost of doing so and that Wesfarmers, the Coles parent, will have better investment ideas.
This is reinforced when I study the strengths and weaknesses of the two chains.
The store count is Woolworths with 1240+ trading as Dan Murphy, Woolworths Liquor and BWS and Coles with 780+ trading as 1st Choice, Liquorland, and Vintage Cellars. Over the last six or so years Woolworths has been active opening new stores while Coles has done very little.
Woolworths Liquor
The Woolworths flagship is Dan Murphy and they have turned a Melbourne concept into the most formidable retail force in Australia. The brand perception has translated into a powerful position as good as anything developed in any country and indeed I do not think it has an equal anywhere. From cheap beer to fine wine they cover the lot and have made themselves the ultimate 'big-box' retailer with enormous depth of stock.
Next are the stores attached to supermarkets, Woolworths Liquor, which provides convenience liquor to supermarket customers. As the year roll by and the movement of licenses and the granting of new licenses becomes easier this is the chain which will expand.
The free standing BWS stores are smaller than Dan Murphy and are also the stores attached to hotels. They are the mid tier between Dan's and those linked to supermarkets. Many were previously successful independent stores with most in excellent locations with some acting as drive inns. BWS nicely covers the convenience market outside the range of Woolworths Liquor. Please note that with restrictions on licensing you simply cannot open a store where you might wish, so at this stage BWS have a large role and are very competitive.
The three brands make sense with each having an identified market position and as such are manageable by a large organisation.
If only it were the same for Coles as the current branding makes little sense.
Coles Liquor
The Coles equivalent of Dan Murphy is 1st Choice Liquor Superstore (spelt as Cho1stce in advertisements). Coles took too long to respond to the threat of 'big-box' retailing and when moves were made they were half hearted. A Dan Murphy store built from scratch is a different proposition to a medium or large sized liquor store having its name changed to 1st Choice. The first was opened in July, 2005 and by 2006 they knew the brand was not working. In the years since this perception by consumers has not improved.
The Australian, 3rd and 6th August, retail articles by Blair Speedy based on documents leaked from Coles explained:
"The company after finding that the 1st Choice name is "too generic", and, "Coles says its 1st Choice wine offering has failed to establish its credentials as a retailer of fine wine to rival Dan Murphy's, instead being seen by consumers as mainly a place to buy cheap beer in bulk."
I recall the excitement of the Coles liquor executives in 2005 when they unfolded the findings of months of research to reveal the challenge to Dan Murphy would be called 1st Choice. It was explained the '1st' would mean things like, first choice for customers, first choice for boutique beers, first choice for all liquor categories'; which suggested at the time that they had failed to grasp the enormous power and simplicity of the Dan Murphy offer.
Now it can be seen that 1st Choice is a doubtful and perhaps a losing proposition sitting as it does as a poor man's Dan Murphy. Dan's has powerful momentum and it would need brilliant retailing to flag to customers that there is an equal.
The second of the Coles chains is Vintage Cellars with 80+ stores which opened its first shop in Mosman back in 1983-84. The idea back then was to target the premium wine market which wasn't catered for by the Liquorland convenience stores. The market has changed dramatically in the years since and the relevance and future of this chain must be of concern.
From The Australian; "According to the Coles documents, its Vintage Cellars stores were seen as too upmarket and so were losing customers whenever Woolworths opened a Dan Murphy's outlet within 5km". An example is the closure of six or so Vintage Cellars in Adelaide as Dan Murphy expanded. This suggests the Vintage Cellars offering is weak and also highlights that the need for premium up-market stores is limited. Thus in some areas such as the north shore of Sydney there are far too many. It remains a mystery why one of the great liquor stores in Australia, which rivalled Crittendens of Toorak for large turnover at mouth watering margins, the former Theos at Neutral Bay, was branded Vintage Cellars. The turnover dropped from $140,000 per week to $60,000 and is still slipping.
Vintage Cellars is also a difficult proposition to manage as the range of imported wines and the reliance on a monthly catalogue requires experts to manage which is not a strength of supermarket focussed executives. In any case who now sees Vintage Cellars as credible fine wine merchants? Something drastic will have to be done to this chain as many of the sites are very good and can be put to more profitable use.
Woolworths has no direct equivalent with an initial experiment branding stores as First Estate being discontinued in July, 2005. For Woolworths the fine wine buyer is adequately catered for by Dan Murphy's.
The convenience stores are branded Liquorland the name being derived from a small Sydney chain purchased around 1980(?). Liquorland is a combination of Woolworths BWS and Woolworths Liquor as the stores are associated with supermarkets as well as free standing and drive-in outlets. The liquor retail strategy of Coles is puzzling as a recent new Coles Supermarket in the Sydney north shore suburb of Balgowlah has at the entrance a Vintage Cellars not a Liquorland. Like all Vintage Cellars the wine range includes many imported wines which I cannot see having any appeal at all to the average shopper leaving the supermarket. After 37 years in the wine business I think I have a fair knowledge of the world's wines but the selection baffles me.
It is apparent that the Coles liquor offering has many problems and this grows when the two chains are compared State by State.
In Victoria, Coles are beaten and I do not think it possible for 1st Choice, even with massive investment to take any share from Dan Murphy. They are also beaten in South Australia as Dan Murphy and BWS are now too strong. Coles are slipping in New South Wales though they have many very good locations but as yet no move has been made to place serious money on the table to buy land and build from scratch stores equivalent to Dan Murphy. The situation in Queensland is better as Coles have some great hotel sites but so does Woolworths. The battle continues in Western Australia though the recent purchase of the Compass Hotel Group of 12 hotels by Woolworths in August 2011 is a massive setback for Coles.
In 2006 reports appeared that Coles was considering changing the liquor brands to variation around the Coles brand and this was mentioned at Doing Hand Stands at the Dorchester. From The Australian, August 3rd, 2011, Blair Speedy:
"The company is also considering changing the brand to Coles Liquor Superstore after finding that the 1st Choice name is "too generic". The Liquorland name is set to be rebadged as Coles Liquor."
Coles must do something quickly as the current strategy is not working and using the Coles brand while risky does shift the brand perception very quickly.
Help for Coles?
New Zealand deregulated the liquor market through the 1990s and are further advanced than Australia. This was covered at Big Box Liquor and the New Zealand Market.
One effect has been that customers feel well serviced by buying wines in supermarkets and 'big box liquor barns' have not thrived. Wine displays in New Zealand supermarkets are very well done.
In the early-mid 2000s it was rumoured that Woolworths was taking the Dan Murphy brand to New Zealand. The decision not to proceed was no doubt based on the consideration that the offer may not succeed. There is also no real equivalent to Dan Murphy in the UK dominated as it is by supermarkets and a deregulated liquor market.
A few weeks ago Aldi supermarkets were granted 35 new licenses in New South Wales which continues the trend to dismantle the State based liquor regulations which stretch back to 1975 when the Canberra market was the first to deregulate.
If Woolworths has a weakness it is that of total deregulation which would allow all of the Coles supermarkets to be licensed. Now that really would change the game. Would you then need all of the giant free standing Dan Murphy stores?
|
2 0 1 4
2 0 1 3
2 0 1 2
2 0 1 1
2 0 1 0
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 7
2 0 0 6
2 0 0 5
2 0 0 4
|
The Story of Penfolds Wine Storage Cabinets and Old Fashioned DiscountingFriday, 5th September 2014
Coles Liquor Shows Signs of LifeFriday, 1st August, 2014
The Dog Days of Being an Independent RetailerMonday, 24th March, 2014
Crumbling Brand Access Fees for New Zealand Sauvignon BlancMonday, 17th March, 2014
Matua and Real New Zealand Being Made in AustraliaThursday, 27th February, 2014
The 2014 Release of the Penfolds BinsThursday, 20th February, 2014
Matua Marlborough and VintrepreneurFriday, 31st January, 2014
Service and Shopping Experience versus The DealThursday, 23rd May, 2013
Personal Experiences with Mataro in AustraliaFriday, 22nd March, 2013
It's Mataro - Not MourvèdreFriday, 15th March, 2013
New Moves Selling Wine OnlineFriday, 8th March, 2013
The U.S. Oil Industry, Bordeaux and Australian Fine WineMonday, 11th February, 2013
Wine and Innovation Fashions Fads and Targeting Consumers TypesTuesday, 11th December, 2012
The Liquor Wars - Matt Skinner AppearsMonday, 19th November, 2012
A Black Swan Event Hits the WestWednesday, 31st October, 2012
Queen Adelaide Becomes No Name GirlThursday, 28th June, 2012
The Seven Teachings of Harry Brown 1918-1999Friday, 15th June, 2012
When Does an Escort become a High Class EscortTuesday, 29th May, 2012
Multi-Nationals Looking for Desirable BrandsThursday, 3rd May, 2012
Extending the Sauvignon Blanc BrandSunday, 18th December, 2011
Coles Continues the War on Liquor Prices - Woolworths is BoredSunday, 20th November, 2011
Liquor Price War DeclaredSunday, 20th November, 2011
The Liquor Wars - Woolworths is Killing ColesTuesday, 8th November, 2011
The Brand Access Fee and Wines Labelled AC/DCTuesday, 16th August, 2011
The Good Taste of UK ConsumersTuesday, 16th August, 2011
Wolf Blass Eaglehawk at $4.99Tuesday, 12th July, 2011
The Battle for the Penfolds DollarMonday, 21st March, 2011
Woolworths and Coles Like the Taste of New Zealand SaveeMonday, 14th March, 2011
Putting the Bling Back in ChampagneMonday, 21st February, 2011
Real Wine Drinkers Discussing FavouritesMonday, 21st February, 2011
Keeping Up with the Big RetailersFriday, 11th June 2010
It's 2010 Not 2000Friday, 28th May, 2010
Grange Spin from Peter GagoFriday, 21st May, 2010
What are Wines Worth and Pointing WinesFriday, 26th February, 2010
Killing the Champagne BrandTuesday, 9th February, 2010
Champagnes - the New Leaders at HarrodsFriday, 5th February, 2010
Two Co-Branded Yalumba WinesWednesday, 27th January, 2010
Are High Priced Wines Worth the Money?Thursday, 8th October, 2009
The Strange Case of Wolf Blass VeraeThursday, 24th September, 2009
Is There A Connection Between Three Seemingly Different Trends?Thursday, 13th August, 2009
Tintara - An Exclusive Wine for Dan MurphySaturday, 1st August, 2009
The Fresh Food People Strike AgainSaturday, 11th July, 2009
We All Love a Wine BargainMonday, 6th April, 2008
The Strange World of Liquor Retailing in 2009Tuesday, 10th March, 2008
Awash In a Sea of SaveeMonday, 28th November, 2008
53 Million Cases to ManyWednesday, 19th November, 2008
More on Grays On-LineWednesday, 19th November, 2008
The Origin of the Fosters Multi Beverage StrategySunday, 9th November, 2008
Bargains or Not on Grays OnlineSunday, 19th October, 2008
Is It The End of Nine Glorious Years?Monday, 13th October, 2008
Will Virtual Wine Companies Work? Sunday, 31st August, 2008
A Story about Mixing Wine and BeerSunday, 17th August, 2008
The Changing Tastes of Wine DrinkersSunday, 17th August, 2008
The Really Bad News About Sliding ExportsWednesday, 13th August, 2008
Wine Facts, Trends, Fads and HopeTuesday, 20th May, 2008
The Steady Decline of Tier One Wine CompaniesFriday, 9th May, 2008
Is It All Too Hard at Fosters?Sunday, 24th February, 2008
Who Would Have Thought of This!Tuesday, 19th February, 2008
Thank Goodness for AldiMonday, 11th February, 2008
A Pleasant Day Online at Grays AuctionsFriday, 3rd August, 2007
Wine Prices, Point Scores and RetailingThursday, 2nd August, 2007
A Useful Marketing LessonThursday, 26th July, 2007
The Dan Murphy View of CleanskinsTuesday, 17th July, 2007
Wine Slabs for Queen AdelaideTuesday, 10th July, 2007
Cheers I Hope You Enjoy the Blue NunMonday, 14th May, 2007
Sauvignon Blanc Sweeps All Before ItSaturday, 12th May, 2007
They Do Things Differently in TasmaniaFriday, 11th May, 2007
New Zealand Grab the Number One SpotSunday, 6th May, 2007
Woolworths Keeps Hammering AwayTuesday, 24th April, 2007
The Liquor Retailer Who Forgot How to Retail - Coles LiquorlandSunday, 22nd April, 2007
Conversations with a Sydney Liquor MerchantThursday, 12th April, 2007
Woolworths Charges AheadSunday, 8th April, 2007
Do You Recall Recommended Retail Prices?Sunday, 8th April, 2007
Cleanskin Shopping at Dan MurphyFriday, 30th March, 2007
Fosters - the Incredible Shrinking Wine CompanyTuesday, 27th March, 2007
Please, Please We Need More CompetitionMonday, 19th March, 2007
The Slow Death of a Great Brand - PenfoldsThursday, 15th March, 2007
What Do Fosters and Coles Have in Common?Tuesday, 8th March, 2007
News on the 2007 VintageTuesday, 6th March, 2007
Dan Strikes AgainFriday, 23rd February, 2007
Liquorland - The Future of RetailingTuesday, 30th January, 2006
Australia's Top 100 WinesThursday, 7th December, 2006
The Return of the Price Fighting VortexSunday, 3rd December, 2006
Ah! To Make a Wine with Aspirational StatusTuesday, 28th November, 2006
The Unusual Marketing at Brown BrosTuesday, 7th November, 2006
English Speakers Embrace WineTuesday, 17th October, 2006
What Comes After Barossa Pearl and Ben Ean?Monday, 18th September, 2006
High Alcohols and Bad Press About Australian WineThursday, 14th September, 2006
Crown Lager Crashes the Wine WeekendTuesday, 29th August, 2006
Rosemount Slides AwayWednesday, 23rd August, 2006
Wiping Your Hands and Ducking for CoverTuesday, 15th August, 2006
Talking with English Wine Merchant, Noel YoungFriday, 11th August, 2006
The Sky Darkens for RoséphobesWednesday, 9th August, 2006
Doing Hand Stands at the DorchesterTuesday, 1st August, 2006
How Does $5000 a Bottle Sound for Ch. Petrus 2005Tuesday, 25th July, 2006
We Did It Because We CouldMonday, 24th July, 2006
Wine Prices and MillionairesThursday, 22nd June, 2006
Why Are Cleanskins So Popular?Friday, 26th May, 2006
Rosé Raises Its Ugly HeadWednesday, 24th May, 2006
The Release of the 2001 Grange and Old MemoriesThursday, 11th May, 2006
A Retailer With a Sense of HumourMonday, 17th April, 2006
What About the Steak Knives?Monday, 10th April, 2006
Little Penguin Joins Yellow Tail in Top TenFriday, 7th April, 2006
Grange Over Priced Says AuctioneerTuesday, 21st March, 2006
White Drinkers Move Up While Clean Skins Take Red Drinkers DownWednesday, 8th March, 2006
Woolies Keeps Growing While Coles Plays Catch UpWednesday, 8th March, 2006
Gobbledegook from ColesTuesday, 21st February, 2006
Great Vintages Growing on TreesTuesday, 31st January, 2006
An Insight Into Clean SkinsTuesday, 31st January, 2006
Retail Concentration ContinuesFriday, 16th December, 2005
Big Box Number SevenThursday, 15th December, 2005
Fine Wine Price Slump PredictedSunday, 9th December, 2005
BEATEN!Tuesday, 6th December, 2005
'Two for' and '20% Off for Six' - Retailers Follow the Changing LeaderWednesday, 30th November, 2005
Coles Performs Predictably PoorlyFriday, 11th November, 2005
The Chasm Between Woolworths Liquor and Coles Liquor Will Create ProblemsThursday, 3rd November, 2005
And the Strong Get StrongerThursday, 27th October, 2005
And No Wonder - The $2.99 Wine Bottle is BackThursday, 27th October, 2005
The Clean Skin Surge ContinuesThursday, 27th October, 2005
Could it be True - Rosé is Rising?Thursday, 13th October, 2005
Bargain Priced, Well Made French WinesMonday, 22nd August, 2005
A Taste of Cleanskins from Dan MurphyThursday, 18th August, 2005
Winestate Recomends Orlando Jacobs Creek Reserve ShirazWednesday, 17th August, 2005
The Price Vortex Gathers SpeedWednesday, 3rd August, 2005 [Sydney]
Woolworths Quietly Rebadge First Estate to BWSSaturday, 30th July, 2005
It’s All Happening at the Dee Why Hotel, the Northern Beaches, SydneySunday, 24th July, 2005
Some Thoughts for Ms. Lucas - Liquor Retailing in AustraliaSunday, 24th July, 2005
The Price Fighting Varietals and the Spiralling Price VortexSunday, 24th July, 2005
What Does the Tussle Between Woolworths and ColesMyer in Liquor Mean For Wine Consumers?Thursday, 16th June, 2005
Wynns Cabernet for $16.99 and Thoughts on Clean SkinsFriday, 13th May, 2005
High End Wines Catch a ColdSaturday, 16th April, 2005
The Release of the Penfolds 2002 Bin Reds plus a Great RieslingMonday, 28th February, 2005
A Good Cheap French ChampagneFriday, 28th January, 2005
One of the Best Buys in RedWednesday, 21st November, 2004
The Good Times Are With UsWednesday, 17th November, 2004
Glug visits the Adelaide Wine ShowFriday, 8th October, 2004
Shopping at LiquorlandFriday, 1 October, 2004
A Great Kiwi, A Great Italian And More 2002 RedsWednesday, 29th September, 2004
The Barossa Wine Show, September, 2004Monday, 25th September, 2004
A Quick Trip to Dan Murphy'sFriday, 24th September, 2004
|
|