Username:    Password:
Thanks for stopping by...
The International Wine Industry
Wishing Jefferson Had Drunk It
Wednesday, 6th September, 2006  - Richard Farmer
Malcolm Forbes - "I wish Jefferson had bloody drunk the thing."

Having paid £105,000 in 1985 for what the auctioneers described as a bottle of 1787 Lafite, the publishing magnate Malcolm Forbes put his prized new possession in a glass case equipped with halogen spotlights so people could see it in all its glory. It was the world’s most expensive wine, not just because of its age and first growth status, but because of its provenance.

This was a bottle miraculously discovered after two centuries walled up in a Parisian cellar where Thomas Jefferson himself had stored it. "Th. J." was etched on the bottle and no less an authority than Michael Broadbent, Master of Wine, was vouching for its authenticity.

And there on its pedestal the wine sat with the cork drying out until it dropped into the bottle. "I wish", commented the billionaire, "Jefferson had bloody drunk the thing."

Fellow American rich men, William Koch a chemical engineer of California, and Russell Frye, a Massachusetts software entrepreneur, are not proving quite so philosophical about other bottles with the Th. J. monogram that they paid fortunes for. Their concern is not that a little re-corking might be necessary to preserve their old vintages but evidence that the wine is not really old at all.

Mr. Koch filed suit in federal court in New York this week against a German collector and dealer, Hardy Rodenstock, who supplied the Jefferson bottles and other rare vintages to auction houses and merchants. Mr. Koch, the Wall Street Journal reported, alleges that the former pop-music promoter defrauded him and engaged in a scheme to deceive wine buyers and reviewers around the world. Mr Frye has filed suit in federal court in San Francisco against a California distributor that sold him Mr. Rodenstock's wines.

James Gabler - author of "An Evening with Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson"

A writer and lecturer on Jefferson's passion for wines, James Gabler, was instrumental in Messrs Koch and Frye taking action. Mr Gabler whose book "An Evening with Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson" was published this year by Bacchus Press, responded on a website in February this year to a request for information about the authenticity of the Jefferson wines. He wrote:

There are a number of compelling reasons why the 1787 Lafite wine bottle engraved with the initials "Th.J." and sold at auction by Christie's in London on December 5, 1985 for $156,450, amongst a cache of bottles found by Hardy Rodenstock "behind a bricked up wall in Paris," was not, in my opinion, ever owned or possessed by Thomas Jefferson. According to the Christie's catalog the cache of bottles included "a bottle of 1787 Chateau d'Yquem ... From the same bricked up paris cellar Mr. Rodenstock also acquired three bottles of 1787 Branne Mouton, (now Mouton Rothschild), Chateau Margau [sic],the Lafite and another bottle of Yquem."

First, an examination of Jefferson's records reveals that he never owned or ordered any Bordeaux wines of the 1787 vintage, and those records include his letters, his log of records written and received, whole parcels of his miscellaneous accounts, including the internal customs documents accompanying his wine shippments from Bordeaux to Paris, and, most importantly his daily financial memorandum books recording all his receipts and expenditures, in which Jefferson put so much faith that he said he would vouch in their accuracy and completeness 'on the bed of death.'

Second, Jefferson kept an accout of all expenses relating to his purchases of wines, and there are no references in Jefferson's records of having purchased Bordeaux wines engraved with his initials.

Third, Jefferson DID NOT arrange 'for his agent in Bordeaux to supply bottles engraved for identification , with vintage, name of chateau and his initials' as Michael Broadbent contends in his recent book. On the contrary, in his Bordeaux wine order of September 1790 for himself and President George Washington he instructed the vineyard owners to mark the outside packages G.W. and T.J. and told his Bordeaux agent, Joseph Fenwick, that Fenwick would receive the wines from the vineyards "ready packed." For Fenwick to have had the bottles engraved would have required the removal of bottles from their cases so each bottle could be engraved, an expensive undertaking not accounted for in Jefferson's records.

Jefferson's records are totally silent on the wine of "Branne Mouton," and there is only one mention of "Mouton" and that is in reference to a third catagory of wines. He never ordered Mouton. The wine Jefferson esteemed after the four first growths was Madame de Rozan's wine, now Rozan-Segla.

Also, the provenance of everything is vital to its authenticity, and the fact that Mr. Rodenstock has refused to tell how and where he obtained the bottles, beyond saying that they were found in a "bricked-up Paris cellar," is troubling. If we knew where Mr. Rodenstock had obtained the bottles, their idenity could be established, and any possible connection to Jefferson, traced. Rodenstock's refusal to reveal how and where he got the bottles obscures that simple solution.

A more detailed account of the reasons why the "Th.J" bottles were not owned by Jefferson can be found in "An Evening with Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson: Dinner, Wine, and Conversation" at pages 124-131 and 313-317.

I have not seen any comment by Mr Broadbent MW, now aged 79 but still a consultant to Christies, on the controversy. "Looking back, more questions could have been asked," Richard Brierley, who is head of Christie's U.S. wine sales but wasn't involved in the 1985 auction told the Wall Street Journal. At the time, Mr. Broadbent, the renowned wine author and Christie's board member, had vouched for the bottles and backed Mr. Rodenstock. "When more Jefferson bottles surfaced later, that cast a cloud on them," Mr. Brierley said.

Supermarket Power

Tuesday, 17th April, 2011

China's Increasing Role In The World Wine Business

Tuesday, 17th April, 2011

While We Dream Of Exports Others Get Ready For Chinese Imports

Sunday, 18th December, 2011

Some Advice For Wine Marketing Managers

Sunday, 27th November, 2011

Wine investment Chinese Style

Tuesday, 6th September, 2011

A Wide Gulf Divides the Wine Trade

Sunday, 24th July, 2011

Forget the Food Bit - Just Give Me a Drink

Friday, 1st July, 2011

Chinese Wine Market Developing Nicely

Wednesday, 12th January, 2011

Perhaps the Barossa Should Make One

Monday, 20th December, 2010

A Comic Way to International Fame

Monday, 6th December, 2010

Goodness Knows What They Drink It With

Monday, 29th November, 2010

The State of the Modern Wine Industry

Tuesday, 16th November, 2010

Up Date on the Liquor Wars

Tuesday, Friday, 26th March 2010

French fight back

Tuesday, 9th March 2010

Dinner with Sandra Tavares - Portuguese Winemaker

Thursday, 19th February, 2010

Get Ready for the Citrus Tang of Koshu

Wednesday, 18th November, 2009

A Luncheon Address from Jancis Robinson

Tuesday, 17th February, 2009

In Praise of Gimblett Gravels

Thursday, 1st January, 2009

Catching Up with World Wine Consumption

Friday, 21st November, 2008

An Update on World Wine Consumption and Production

Tuesday, 18th November, 2008

The Great Wines of Italy

Thursday, 15th May, 2008

Yearning For A Faulty Wine

Friday, 31st August, 2007

All Is Not What It Seems with Chinese Wine

Friday, 31st August, 2007

Grateful for the Mistake

Tuesday, 31st July, 2007

The Real Wine Boom in China

Wednesday, 25th July, 2007

Remembering the Sopranos

Tuesday, 17th July, 2007

A Rat of a Wine

Friday, 13th July, 2007

Mildew Threatens Bordeaux

Friday, 13th July, 2007

Wayne Gretzky and an Australian Connection

Tuesday, 3rd July, 2007

Will the Pressure Ever End?

Sunday, 1st July, 2007

The Danes are Preparing

Sunday, 1st July, 2007

What Wine Do You Put In a Counterfeit Ch. Lafite?

Tuesday, 12th June, 2007

New Zealand’s Fame Keeps Spreading

Thursday, 19th April, 2007

The New Zealand Landscape, Wines and Amazing Export Growth

Wednesday, 21st February, 2007

Artful Prince Astonishes Wine World

Sunday, 14th January, 2007

That Dreaded Global Warming

Sunday, 14th January, 2007

World Wine Sales Stagnant

Sunday, 29th October, 2006

Illegal for Italians but Paris Makes it Great for Germans

Saturday, 28th October, 2006

New Zealand Wine Storms Ahead

Tuesday, 12th September, 2006

Wishing Jefferson Had Drunk It

Wednesday, 6th September, 2006

Not a Little Critter

Wednesday, 6th September, 2006

A Welcome Cease Fire

Saturday, 26th August, 2006

Sniffing a Fraud

Thursday, 24th August, 2006

Producers and Drinkers Disagree

Saturday, 22nd July, 2006

Sherry - a Seven Century Epic of Sales

Tuesday, 18th July, 2006

A Rap Over the Knuckles for Duboeuf

Friday, 14th July, 2006

A Brave Promise from the Euro Commissioner

Wednesday, 14th June, 2006

Wine Down a Russian Sink

Sunday, 11th June, 2006

A Dangerous Thing Those Blind Tastings

Sunday, 11th June, 2006

Looking Back - Can It Help Us Look Forward?

Thursday, 18th May, 2006

Russia's Wine War

Saturday, 29th April, 2006

A Portuguese Traitor

Friday, 21st April, 2006

The Exchange Rates Works Their Magic: Argentine Exports Increase

Tuesday, 18th April, 2006

Duboeuf Trial Begins

Saturday, 8th April, 2006

And the Big Get Bigger

Wednesday, 5th April, 2006

Some Spanish Assistance

Wednesday, 5th April, 2006

Russian Wine Ban

Tuesday, 4th April, 2006

Big Box Liquor and the New Zealand Market

Thursday, 23th February, 2006

A State Wine for California

Thursday, 16th February, 2006

Critter Market Increasing Its Share

Friday, 27th January, 2006

Millenials Like Cute Labels

Saturday, 21st January, 2006

Label Design Important

Friday, 30th December, 2005

Bitters for Marie Brizard

Thursday, 22nd December, 2005

Madonnalicious Wine

Wednesday, 21 December, 2005

Duboeuf Fraud Charges Proceed

Tuesday, 20th December, 2005

Lanson Bidders Retreat

Wednesday, 14th December, 2005

Bid for Vincor Withdrawn

Monday, 12th December, 2005

A Victory for Banal Industrial Process?

Tuesday, 6th December, 2005

A Self Imposed Boycott in Bordeaux

Monday, 5th December, 2005

A Drought for Sauvignon Blanc?

Tuesday, 29th November, 2005

The Bid Goes On and the Bidder's Price Goes Lower

Tuesday, 29th November, 2005

French Varietal Marketing Expands

Tuesday, 22nd November, 2005

A French Fight Back?

Tuesday, 22 November 2005

Rapid Growth from Small Base

Tuesday, 22nd November, 2005

Brewers Seek Inspiration from Milk

Monday, 14th November, 2005

The Good Spirit to the Rescue

Thursday, 10th November, 2005

Goering's Raccoons Threaten German Vineyards

Wednesday, 26th October, 2005

Add Meritage to Your Vocabulary

Monday, 24th October, 2005

Californian Crop Larger Than Expected

Thursday, 20th October, 2005

Diageo Says "No" to Montana

Thursday, 20th October, 2005

Consternation for Constellation

Tuesday, 18th October, 2005

The Pursuit Goes On

Tuesday, 18th October, 2005

Has Constellation Wines Got too Big?

Thursday, 13th October, 2005

An Update on New Zealand

Wednesday, 12th October, 2005

Growing on Wine's Back

Monday, 10th October, 2005

Decentralisation the Constellation Cornerstone

Friday, 30th September, 2005

Goundrey in Billion $ Bid

Thursday, 29th September, 2005

Massachusetts Plan to Ban Wine Deliveries

Monday, 19th September, 2005

France's Declining Wine Market

Monday, 19th September, 2005

Wines on the Back of His Hand

Tuesday, 13th September, 2005

A Spanish Sushi Wine?

Wednesday, 7th September, 2005

Italians Revolting Too!

Wednesday, 31st August, 2005

Outside the Chateau, the Peasants are Revolting

Monday, 29th August, 2005

Deceit on the Goods at Georges Duboeuf

Saturday, 27th August, 2005

Wine Passes Beer in UK Sales

Tuesday, 23rd August, 2005

Wine Investment Comes to Japan

Wednesday, 17th August, 2005

The French Still Revolting

Wednesday, 2nd June, 2005

©2019 Glug  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |   RSS Feed
Liquor Licensing Act 1997: It is an offence to sell or supply liquor to a person under the age of 18 years, or to obtain liquor on behalf of a person under the age of 18 years.
All transactions in $AUD. This web site is operated by Glug Management Company Pty Ltd ABN: 64 116 647 780 Licence No: 57701982