ACCC Attacks the Hero
Tuesday, 12th August, 2008
- David Farmer
"I wonder whether Mr Samuel has been living on the moon."
The hard working executives at Metcash, who saved the independent grocery trade, must be wondering "Why us?" when they read the recent government commissioned report on the grocery industry. The ACCC wrongly concluded that if the independent grocery trade had another wholesaler to buy from they would be able to compete more vigorously against each other and Coles and Woolworths.
Reluctantly they also concluded that maybe it is not profitable enough for two independent wholesalers. Exactly, so be happy that we have at least one that is good and profitable. And recall who allowed the dominance of Coles and Woolworths to occur-why none other than the ACCC.
John David spent a decade joining all the state based independent grocery wholesalers into a large outfit that could compete with Coles and Woolworths. He had to do this as independent retailers were losing market share rapidly, and basically were a disjointed rabble and he could see his family business becoming worthless. He almost pulled it off but management issues in integration almost drove the listed company broke. In 1997 you could buy the forerunner of Metcash for around 40 cents a share. Fortunately some tough South Africans saw an opportunity, put up the money and took over John David's company, Davids Holdings. The fact that we have a thriving independent grocery trade is due to their hard work.
So what does Graeme Samuel say in commenting about the grocerychoice.com web site: "You can see that in 52 of 61 regions, Coles is cheaper, and that the independent outlets are uncompetitive across most of the regions. If I was an executive at one of those retailers, I would be thinking, 'How long can we survive with a reputation as the most expensive outlet?' I would consider changing my pricing practices."
I wonder whether Mr Samuel has been living on the moon. How can an independent wholesaler who will not be buying as well as Coles and Woolworths, and who is in many cases supplying sub standard grocery shops, many who buy in small volume, supposed to make them competitive with Coles and Woolworths. An independent close to a Coles or Woolworths will not survive and mostly but nor entirely the banner groups under the Metcash umbrella provide a supermarket service from smaller suburban centres, small country towns, strip shopping, localised and hard to reach areas in cities and other out of the way locations. Alas they do not have enough stores the equal of Coles and Woolworths. As these stores I guess would cost tens of millions to build and fit-out perhaps Mr Samuel can tell us how a family business is meant to find this type of money. Metcash does do a lot to assist as it's in their interests to have independents thriving. But to then take on Woolworths with price-no thanks. Metcash has in fact done better than it should have as they have been able to feed off the very weak effort over the last decade of Coles. Thank goodness Aldi has arrived and pray that Costco goes ahead.
I leave the last word to Henry Ergas writing in the Australian, 11th August:
"The best that can be said is that though the analysis on which it is based is shallower than a Murray dam, GroceryChoice does not seem as harmful as FuelWatch. But surely the public can expect better of the competition regulator. Is the ACCC really incapable of looking at a market without wanting to tinker with it? Why wouldn't the ACCC give frank advice that gimmicks such as GroceryChoice merely waste taxpayers' money?"
|
2 0 1 2
2 0 1 1
2 0 1 0
2 0 0 9
2 0 0 8
2 0 0 7
2 0 0 6
2 0 0 5
2 0 0 4
|
Road Kill Across AustraliaFriday, 19th October, 2012
Using Up That Wine SurplusMonday, 9th January, 2011
The Critics Defend Their RatingsMonday, 5th October, 2009
More Great Times for the FoodiesFriday, 2nd October, 2009
A Great Time for the FoodiesSaturday, 12th September, 2009
Will it be Lawyers over the Dining Room Table?Saturday, 1st August, 2009
A Small Tribute to Frank Devine - Marketing and ManagerialismSunday, 5th July, 2009
Tall Geological Tales, Uranium and Other ThingsThursday, 28th May, 2009
Tall Geological Tales, Uranium and Other ThingsThursday, 28th May, 2009
The ACCC Gets It Wrong on GroceriesFriday, 24th April, 2009
One Makes Cars the Other Wine - The Result is the SameSunday, 19th April, 2009
Let Anarchy Rule the RoadsMonday, 17th September, 2007
When Cruel Death AppearsWednesday, 15th August, 2007
What He Drank Last NightTuesday, 31st July, 2007
The Name We Dare Not MentionTuesday, 24th July, 2007
Pine Creek and Ah ToySunday, 1st July, 2007
Opinion Polls and the Dressed Weight of a Particular Living OxWednesday, 23rd May, 2007
Brushing Your Teeth with a Deadly GlycolWednesday, 23rd May, 2007
A Clutch of Double EntendresSunday, 29th April, 2007
A Picture of Global Warming?Friday, 2nd March, 2007
Memories of OtisTuesday, 20th February, 2007
Grog For Your DogFriday, 26th January, 2007
Chunky Joins the Telegraph HatersWednesday, 17th January, 2006
The Rarely Seen Titan ArumSunday, 12th November, 2006
The Flavours of BeerWednesday, 8th November, 2006
Woof, Woof to the Rescue of the Little PenguinsWednesday, 1st November, 2006
Methadone Fails 97% Of Drug Addicts And Flu Vaccines Don't Help MuchSunday, 29th October, 2006
American Fatties Cause Global Warming - The Fat Report No. 2Sunday, 29th October, 2006
Relations Between Australia and United States ThreatenedTuesday, 24th October, 2006
The Fat Report - a Round Up of Obesity NewsMonday, 23rd October, 2006
Newman's Horse RadishSaturday, 2nd September, 2006
Woolworths Cooks up a TreatMonday, 21st August, 2006
Giving the Mob a Helping HandWednesday, 19th July, 2006
A Soccer Setback for Satellite SalesMonday, 17th July, 2006
Worse than Pubs With No Beer – Restaurants Without Wine!Tuesday, 11th July, 2006
The More Things Change...Friday, 7th July, 2006
Forget the Rum, Try a CachaçaFriday, 23th June, 2006
An Anniversary RememberedTuesday, 13th June, 2006
Irish Trout and Other MonstersFriday, 2nd June, 2006
Try a Hardy Text and Get a ChardyThursday, 11th May, 2006
Enough to Make a Russian RevoltTuesday, 18th April 2006
A Day of National ShameWednesday, 12th April, 2006
And in the Beginning There Was … AlcoholSaturday, 8th April, 2006
More Perils of Punting: Assistant Coach on IceThursday, 9th February, 2006
Fox Hunting Lives on in South AustraliaThursday, 9th February, 2006
Wine Drinkers Are Healthier Eaters Monday, 6th February, 2006
Understatement of the Week?Thursday, 2nd February, 2006
The Dangers of Betting in Two Player ContestsMonday, 30th January, 2006
Reality Wine MakersFriday, 27th January, 2006
Forget the Zero, a Proper Coke for the Memory PleaseMonday, 16th January, 2006
I'll Have Mine in a Tumbler, ThanksWednesday, 4th January, 2006
Vanilla Beans and Bourbon CasksWednesday, 14th December, 2005
Chinese Drinking Marx But Not Eating HimThursday, 8th December, 2005
How to Encounter a GlugFriday, 2nd December, 2005
An Els of a Wine LaunchWednesday, 30th November, 2005
Wine for Prison PagansMonday, 17th October, 2005
Award for Wine Institute and SA University ScientistsMonday, 10th October, 2005
Kill Two Birds With One EggFriday, 7th October, 2005
|
|